WhiteFlame-XIII's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[2 B With U]

Awesome

Wow. Great sounds. Like the chord progression, and the mindset. Nevermind the fact that the instruments are fake. It's still awesome.

[Viva La Vida Rmx]

Fair Enough but maybe a different take on it.

I like what you did, and how you did it, but it goes against the whole theme of the song. The hip hop approach was well executed for a hip hop approach, but the song wasn't made for a hip hop approach. Now if you had put in some original vocals like a professional Rap artist's remix, it would be amazing. But all you put in was the end line of the song. It also doesn't help that it's too short.

Now what I'm saying is that it's really good for what it is, but it isn't good because of what it is. You do it well, so keep it up, but use a different song next time.

J-ROB26 responds:

again its my first time using samples...so im unfamiliar to chopping up other parts...but thanks for the feedback

[Cello Concerto no. 1 3rd mvnt]

... whatever.

I don't appreciate fake instruments very much. When It comes to classical, I'm a puritan.

However, I found it well done. If you could ever do this in real life, please record this. then, It would be truly amazing.

MusicalRocky responds:

Yeah I hate fake instruments. I hate edirol, I just saw it on google on accident, and thought "whatever," and ordered it.
Yeah, I'm getting this recorded this Friday, the Berlin Philharmonik Orchestra with Yo-yo Ma! Rostropovich AND Karajan are both coming from the dead to conduct it at the same time, and Beethoven's ghost is showing up just to watch (we know how reserved he is.)
I think they're recording it as well, I'll try to get you a copy!

***On a more serious note, this is the second review like this I've had to respond to. If you don't like fake instruments, don't come to the Classical section of NG. We are poor people (most of us) who can't afford a professional recording of an orchestra. The most you'll find is maybe a recorded piano or something similar.***

Also, I'm not trying to be mean, but I'm a little sensitive when people judge my music in this way. I'm glad you enjoyed the piece, and that you listened, and took the time to review.

Rocky

[Prelude no. 5]

Classic. (al)

Not many people appreciate the quality Classical music genre in this day and age. Good job any ways, though. It makes for a good introduction, or prelude as you have hinted to. 5 for you, and good job.

MusicalRocky responds:

Why thank you sir.

Indeed, many people do not like Classical nowadays : ( Oh well, I can only feel bad for them. Anyways, thanks for reviewing, and thanks for the five : )

Rocky

[Six Flags Techno Remix]

Empty

This is already a song. But The way you did this is cheesy and empty. Needs more basis and alot of other things to it. but I voted 5 out of pity

00Nobody responds:

I'm sorry, but I don't like it when you complain about how I do a song. Though it could use more basis, if you've EVER listened to the real song, what I did was NOT very far off from it. I just took the song's notes and rythms, then changed the instruments. You don't have to complain about how i did it, because everyone is different. "I voted 5 out of pity". If you're going to say that I didn't do it right and not give me any help other than 3 words, then give me a 5 "out of pity," don't even bother reviewing it at all. It would be a different story if you had complemented me on it or had actually given far more help than just "Needs more bases and alot of other thing to it." If you had at least given me some ideas on what the "other things" were, I could do the song again, and improve on my work.

[Guitar Vs. Piano 1.2]

hm...

It sounds Artificial... But what the crap. It sounds amazing anyways.

[.pot roast.]

hm...

Pot roast sounds good. This doesn't. I use Reason too. But this is strange, creepy annd makes a bad name for Reason users

VegetarianMeat responds:

This is supposed to be strange and creepy, but hey, we all have different opinions. Once again (see comments), this is my first attempt at a song in Reason, so obviously it's not going to be up to par with other artists who have been using the program for years.

I would say thanks for the review, but you don't give me any real comments on my song besides the apparent fact that you hate it.

[Demtok]

That's a short long one...

so I don't really like it, but 2 just because Some bastard gave me a zero for no reason. not saying it was you.

bearwasdead responds:

I only 0 stuff it it sucks, and people have been doing that to me too.

[no matter]

Yeah. Benny Benassi...

And you really took a good cue from them too...

[<Why?>]

I'm amazed...

It's so awesome... I can't place it... It's just so up there...